Why are balancing capacity, efficiency and cost accounting EVIL?
Watch this video to find out why I say balancing capacity, efficiency and cost accounting are evil. Then I’ll review what you need to do to improve your shop.
What you Accept you get!
Please tell me what you think of the video (what’s not clear, what you still want to know, etc) by leaving a comment! And if you take action based on this video, please share your experience and results. Remember — you can do this anonymously. By Dr Lisa Lang
Yes! I think we are playing Whac-A-Mole!
Lisa… Sounds like you have been reading my material on job shop scheduling. However, your diagnosis of the problem does not make sense. If I want to cut lead time and offer faster service to my customers which is a competitive advantage, then I do not want work languishing in a queue before it hits the floor. I want to get it on the floor as soon as possible because then I can get it out the door sooner. This is different from wanting to maximize utilization.
As far as maximizing utilization of equipment, I agree with you. However, in your example of saw-turn-mill-grind-pack/ship you failed to point out that the saw is a fast operation and can probably out pace every other machine in the process. That means the saw will be idle for a significant portion of the time which is fine. In a machine shop you need particular pieces of equipment when you need them whether or not they are fully utilized.
Seems that you are confusing a mass production build to stock system with a job shop when it comes to processing work. Because work in a job shop is uneven (feast or famine on the input side), lead times will expand and contract with the volume of work unless capacity is managed. (See my article, Do You Know How to Play the Accordion: Managing Capacity in a JOb Shop Environment). I think it was published by SME or maybe FMA.
Anyway, speaking of conventional wisdom which is what TOC has become, you might want to investiage the Theory of Delays which is more applicable to these types of environments.
Hi Vincent. Thank you for your comments, however, you do NOT understand my position. The video may have been confusing. Sorry for that. I am saying you must REDUCE the queues and REDUCE WIP. I agree you want to get work off the floor as soon as possible. We also want to get the work on the floor as soon as possible, but only to the point of some maximum WIP. If we keep shoving work in faster than we are getting it out — WIP goes up, queue time goes up.
And I do not want to maximize the utilization of ALL resources and particularly, to your point, the saw. You are correct that the saw usually has way more capacity than everything else with a few mix exceptions. Conventional Wisdom is to maximize ALL resources (except maybe the saw). If you agree that there is always a bottleneck it will not be possible to maximize all resources unless WIP is really high which means queue time is long.
So, I think maybe we are more in agreement than not.
And, given the number of shops I’ve been in and the challenges people reported, I can say that TOC is NOT even close to Conventional Wisdom. If it were, these problems would not exist or it would be to a much lessor extent.
Sorry to say, I have not read any of your material other than this post. However, I look forward to reading your work. Then I can get a better understanding if we totally agree. 🙂
My analysis of the problem is based on working with a number of shops. In my next video I will start into the direction of the solution and the first step everyone should take TODAY.
Thanks again for taking the time to write!
Lisa
Lisa…I am not understanding your position. If you want to reduce the ques and reduce wip, then you have to increase capacity in order to eliminate the bottleneck. I think you are missing the fact that a bottleneck is a moving target in a job shop environment where line balancing does not apply, all the sources of variation you mention and more come into play, and work coming into the shop is generally feast or famine. A bottle neck may exist one minute and then disappear the next as one of these sources of variation come into play.
Also, I think you conception of a job shop production system as an in-line process…saw…turn…mill…etc. is conventional wisdom from a mass production environment. A job shop production system looks more like a star with all of the points (work centers) interconnected.
I’ll be interested to see how you schedule a shop using TOC.
Vincent,
Sorry for the delay, I was on a flight and then dinner with a client. But I was looking forward to getting back to you! This is fun, thanks!
Your statement “you have to increase capacity in order to eliminate the bottleneck”, I respectfully submit is an assumption. Increasing capacity is A way of dealing with the moving bottleneck, but not the ONLY way. And in my experience, not the best way. It is certainly more risky to make these investments.
I have stated that in job shops the bottleneck DOES move (so we agree on that). And in the video I explained why — because we balance capacity and then the mix changes and the 9 challenges happen. If you increase capacity where a bottleneck appears, you ARE balancing capacity by definition. This is not TOC. But it is what people generally think TOC is saying.
I have been in job shops around the world with Dr Goldratt and I assure you, I do NOT think they are a mass production environment. In fact, I have stated that they are highly custom environments. This highly custom environment is why people have difficulty applying TOC — it is difficult to leverage a moving target.
I’m glad you are open to hearing about a different way of running and scheduling a shop. I will give an overview in my next video and then provide details on the first step.
Thank you for your comments and for allowing me to further explain.
Lisa